Treadstone (2019): Awakened Agents, Unfinished Connections

Treadstone (2019) afişi

Spoiler note: Two sections covering the plot and the season finale are collapsed below. If you haven’t finished the series yet, feel free to skip them.

Working through Han Hyo-joo’s projects, Treadstone let me see the actress in a different production environment. Set in the Jason Bourne universe, this American series follows secret programs operating around the world, agents who get “woken up” and people living without knowing their own past. Its action side managed to keep me interested. Even so, when I finished it, I was left feeling that a large part of the story I’d watched had been saved for a next season.

Credits

Created by Tim Kring

Year / Country 2019 · USA

Network USA Network

Episodes 10 episodes, one season (cancelled in May 2020)

Cast Jeremy Irvine, Brian J. Smith, Tracy Ifeachor, Omar Metwally, Han Hyo-joo, Gabrielle Scharnitzky, Emilia Schüle, Michelle Forbes

Genre Action, spy drama

Based on Operation Treadstone from Robert Ludlum’s Bourne novels

I gave the series a six. Not because I found it a complete failure. My main problem was the disconnect created by the links between its many characters and timelines. Just as I started getting closer to one character’s story, we would jump to another country, another person or the past. While watching, I kept asking the same questions. Where did this person go? Why are we following her now? How will the event we just left connect to this?

Treadstone doesn’t build a story that moves around a single character. It runs several stories at once, stretching from North Korea to Europe and America. It cuts back and forth between present-day events and the agent training and conditioning process set in 1973. The choice aims to show the history of the secret program and its present-day consequences together.

A structure like this has the potential to create curiosity: the viewer sees the pieces first, then waits for the connections between them to emerge. In my experience, though, the pieces multiplied faster than the connections grew stronger. In some transitions, fatigue from simply keeping track joined the curiosity. While I was thinking about how the story would come together, I felt I couldn’t settle into the situations the characters were in.

Spoilers ahead · click to open

The story of John Randolph Bentley and Petra in the past is a clear example. CIA and KGB ties, experiments and personal closeness make up a significant backstory. In the present, we see Petra in Russia, married and living a rural life. The distance between these two eras raises strong questions about who she is. But I wanted to understand more about how she lived over the years and how her old relationships carried on.

So Petra’s reunion with Bentley in the finale wasn’t just a surprising encounter for me. It also made me think again about how much of the life in between had gone untold. Did these people never see each other all those years? What did they know about one another? How did the bond between the life Petra built for herself and her past survive? The reunion scene opens new room for these questions, but doesn’t give them a sufficient answer within the season we watched.

The problem here isn’t that I want every detail explained. It’s natural for a mystery series to hold some information back. But withheld information shouldn’t take the place of the basic connections that would help us understand a character. At times in Treadstone, while getting ready for the next surprise, I felt myself drifting away from the weight of the relationships already on screen.

SoYun Pak, played by Han Hyo-joo, is also one of the characters caught between everyday life and a hidden past. Living as a wife and mother in North Korea, she comes face to face with skills she isn’t fully aware of herself, and that forms the core of her story. Seeing the actress in a different position from her characters in other projects was interesting. But because her story was also constantly slotted in between other storylines, it couldn’t fully close the distance I felt from the series overall.

The side of the series that could reach somewhere intellectually strong is the question of a person’s control over their own life. How much can the everyday identity of someone who doesn’t know their past or their abilities truly belong to them? How should we judge the decisions of a person set in motion by a mission? These questions become even more important when family life collides with the orders of a secret program.

Treadstone places these issues inside the action. I would have liked the characters to stay a little longer with their discoveries about themselves. A skill surfacing, an attack taking place or a new connection opening up quickly turns into the next event. The impact of what happens on the character sometimes falls behind that speed.

This impression is echoed in other reviews too. The NOW Magazine review finds it repetitive that characters in different countries are put through similar awakening-and-confusion arcs. It feels that constantly adding new twists makes the story tiring rather than deeper. That’s quite close to my own criticism of its crowded structure.

Common Sense Media likewise notes that the combination of the script and the flashbacks makes the story hard to follow. It feels the characters have potential, but the writing doesn’t give them enough depth.

AVForums, on the other hand, views the same multi-strand storytelling more positively. It sees the stories set in different times and places as an effective structure and also likes Han Hyo-joo’s action scenes. The review’s hope for a new season shows that the expectation of a continuation, which I felt as something missing, can be a source of intrigue for another viewer.

Season finale spoilers · click to open

For me, the season finale felt less like a completed story and more like the beginning of a much bigger one. The connections opened in the final moments and the characters who reappear give the sense that things were meant to continue in a second season. As it happened, the series was cancelled in May 2020, after its ten-episode first season aired in 2019. The cancellation came during a shift in USA Network’s programming strategy, so it wouldn’t be fair to blame the lack of a continuation on the quality of the writing alone.

Still, for the viewer the result is the same. We’re left alone with some of the questions it opened. And that makes the sense of disconnect that built up over the season even more noticeable for me.

I found Treadstone watchable for its action. But among the number of characters, the time jumps and the connections left for the future, I was looking for a stronger narrative whole. As the episodes went on I was curious, and in the finale I didn’t feel that curiosity was sufficiently rewarded. That feeling of incompleteness is at the root of my six-point rating.

What worked for me

  • Action scenes that keep you engaged
  • Seeing Han Hyo-joo in a different production and an action role
  • The question of identity for someone who doesn’t know their past
  • The program’s backstory, linking 1973 to the present

What didn’t

  • A story split across too many characters and countries
  • Too little time spent on the characters’ discoveries
  • The untold years between Petra and Bentley
  • Connections left for a second season that never came
6/10
My rating

Watchable for its action; the sense of incompleteness set my score.